With a new majority Government there is not just talk of a reshuffle but potentially a more radical reshaping of Whitehall, possibly in February once the EU withdrawal legislation has been passed.
Whilst we wait to see how the new administration will rewire government, I thought about how I would arrange cabinet and the structures of government to make the well being of people and communities and environmental stewardship more prominent.
Any of us can blog and generate ideas but hopefully any actual reform of government and Whitehall will be led by a responsible Minister, not an unelected or unaccountable bureaucrat, and co-designed with all relevant stakeholders, especially those most affected by it.
Government Business (5)
Firstly, there are the cabinet posts providing the central management and coordination of Government.
- Number Ten
Provides strategy and leadership across Government. Sets a framework for lean and enterprising government that combines innovation with tradition and continuous improvement with respect for people.
- Cabinet Office
Oversees government operations, the civil service and the values of public service. The Cabinet Secretary deputises for the prime minister. Our civil service is excellent and this department would ensure it continues to grow, adapt, recruit and advise informed by our best traditions, the principles of public life and future needs.
- Leader of the House of Commons
- Leader of the House of Lords
Manage Parliamentary business across both houses.
- Attorney General’s Office
Provides the government with legal advice.
Offices of State (16)
For me there are four big themes of state: wellbeing, economy, environment and diplomacy. I’d have a Secretary of State for each of these areas as well as for individual departments to improve coordination and joined up thinking at a more strategic level. Each Portfolio Secretary would focus on coordinating three departments as well as cross-portfolio alignment.
Wellbeing
This portfolio would be charged with coordinating policies for happier and healthier people and community based initiatives.
- Communities and People
- Health and Social Care
- Culture, Media and Sport
Health and social care, and culture media and sport I would keep much as they are though with a genuine effort to integrate health and social care for lifelong, community based wellbeing backed by world class specialist expertise. The biggest structural change in this area would be a new department that combined welfare, work and pensions (the current DWP) with responsibility for rights and equalities (a much tossed about floating ministry at the moment), communities and local government and takes over drugs and alcohol policy, immigration policy and vulnerable people from the current Home Office.
Economy
The Chancellor of the Exchequer would lead this portfolio coordinating efforts to improve our prosperity and productivity via a strong, balanced and resourceful economy and secure but flexible employment.
- Treasury
- Industry, Enterprise and Trade
- Knowledge and Skills
The Chief Secretary to the Treasury would have responsibility for the Treasury and fiscal and financial management. Business, industrial policy and international trade would be combined into a single department and there would be a single department for lifelong learning, vocational training, research, innovation and knowledge management.
Environment
This portfolio would be responsible for sustainability ensuring that we, and the diverse life we share our part of the planet with, have healthy, safe places to live and are connected by integrated systems.
- Habitats and Land
- Energy and Networks
- Security and Justice
Habitats and land would look after housing, agriculture, rural affairs and environmental stewardship whilst energy and networks would run our logistical networks from energy, to transport to digital infrastructure. The parts of the Home Office not in communities and people would merge with the Justice ministry to concentrate on our safety and security.
This portfolio looks after our global presence and international relations.
- Foreign and Commonwealth Office
- International Development
- Defence
These departments remain as they are but the overall portfolio ensures the difference facets of our geopolitical functions are better coordinated.
Offices for the Nations (5)
Finally, there are the departments for each of this constituent nations.
- England
- Scotland
- Wales
- Northern Ireland
This should include England. Even though England doesn’t have its own assembly I see no reason why it shouldn’t have its own office of state to represent English matters in government and coordinate with the growing number of metropolitan and civic mayors.
Government Hierarchy
This structure adds in a layer of government hierarchy, the idea of a portfolio of departments, to try and improve joined up thinking across departments. It’s a bit radical because in effect it downgrades the traditional great offices of state and replaces them with the four great portfolios of state.
The levels of seniority in this government organisation would therefore be:
- Prime Minister
- Cabinet Secretary (de facto deputy)
- Secretary of State (Portfolio)
- Secretary of State (Department)
- Minister of State
- Under-Secretary of State